Sensory substitution or enhancement techniques have been proposed to enable deaf or hard of hearing (DHH) people to listen to and even compose music. However, little is known about how such techniques enhance DHH people's music experience. Since deafness is a spectrum -- as are DHH people's preferences and perceptions of music -- a more situated understanding of their interaction with music is needed. To understand the music experience of this population, we conducted social media analyses, both qualitatively and quantitatively, in the deaf and hard of hearing Reddit communities. Our content analysis revealed that DHH people leveraged sign language and visual/haptic cues to feel the music and preferred familiar, non-lyrical, instrument-heavy, and loud music. In addition, hearing aids were not customized for music, and the visual/haptic techniques developed were not widely adopted by DHH people, leading to their suboptimal music experiences. The DHH community embodied mutual support among music lovers, evidenced by active information sharing and Q&A around music and hearing loss. We reflect on design justice for DHH people's music experience and propose practical design implications to create a more accessible music experience for them.
翻译:感官替代或增强技术已被提出,旨在让聋人或听障人士能够聆听甚至创作音乐。然而,关于这些技术如何提升聋人和听障人士音乐体验的研究仍然有限。由于耳聋是一个谱系——聋人和听障人士对音乐的偏好和感知也各不相同——因此需要对其与音乐的互动有更情境化的理解。为深入了解这一群体的音乐体验,我们在聋人和听障人士的Reddit社区中进行了定性和定量的社交媒体分析。内容分析显示,聋人和听障人士借助手语和视觉/触觉线索来感受音乐,并偏好熟悉、无歌词、乐器丰富且音量较大的音乐。此外,助听器并非为音乐而定制,且所开发的视觉/触觉技术并未被聋人和听障人士广泛采用,导致其音乐体验不尽如人意。聋人和听障人士社区体现了音乐爱好者之间的相互支持,这从围绕音乐与听力损失的活跃信息共享和问答中可见一斑。我们反思了聋人和听障人士音乐体验的设计正义,并提出了实用的设计启示,以为他们创造更易访问的音乐体验。