The creative industry is both concerned and enthusiastic about how generative AI will reshape creativity. How might these tools interact with the workflow values of creative artists? In this paper, we adopt a value-sensitive design framework to examine how generative AI, particularly Photoshop's Generative Fill (GF), helps or hinders creative professionals' values. We obtained 566 unique posts about GF from online forums for creative professionals who use Photoshop in their current work practices. We conducted reflexive thematic analysis focusing on usefulness, ease of use, and user values. Users found GF useful in doing touch-ups, expanding images, and generating composite images. GF helped users' values of productivity by making work efficient but created a value tension around creativity: it helped reduce barriers to creativity but hindered distinguishing 'human' from algorithmic art. Furthermore, GF hindered lived experiences shaping creativity and hindered the honed prideful skills of creative work.

翻译：创意产业对生成式AI将如何重塑创造力既感到担忧又充满期待。这些工具将如何与创意艺术家的创作流程价值互动？本文采用价值敏感设计框架，考察生成式AI（特别是Photoshop的生成式填充功能）如何促进或阻碍创意专业人士的价值实现。我们收集了566篇来自创意专业人士在线论坛中关于生成式填充功能的独特帖子，这些从业者均将Photoshop用于日常工作实践。通过反思性主题分析，我们聚焦于工具的实用性、易用性及用户价值。研究发现：用户认为生成式填充在图像修饰、画面扩展和生成合成图像方面具有实用价值；该功能通过提升工作效率满足了用户的生产力需求，但引发了关于创造力的价值张力——它既降低了创作门槛，又模糊了"人类艺术"与算法艺术的界限。此外，生成式填充还削弱了塑造创造力的具身体验，并损害了创意工作中经磨砺形成的技艺自豪感。