Hospitals may need to compare an existing survival prediction model with a candidate before outcomes in their own patients become available. We develop a procedure to support this comparison under explicit assumptions about between-cohort differences and to identify when judgment should be deferred. For two fixed predictors, we derive and prove closed-form sharp bounds on their difference in fixed-horizon Brier risk under bounded, profile-specific conditional survival log-odds shifts. Evaluating both predictors against the same unknown target outcomes yields intervals no wider than subtraction of separately bounded risks. Censoring-adjusted estimation and simultaneous bootstrap confidence envelopes distinguish candidate support, reference support, and deferred judgment. In simulations with a superior reference predictor, separate identified intervals were on average 2.5-2.6 times as wide as direct intervals. At a sensitivity bound of 0.2, correct reference support occurred in 24.8-83.5% of replications with direct identification versus 6.5-19.6% with separate-risk subtraction; incorrect candidate support with direct identification was at most 0.1%. Coverage was 0.88-0.95 with 30% or 50% censoring but fell to 0.79-0.86 under 70% censoring. Three public-data applications examined transfer between hospitals, across time, and between successive clinical studies. Across fixed configurations, separate identified intervals were 1.77-16.4 times as wide as direct intervals. In 100 repeated splits per application, only direct identification supported the candidate at a sensitivity bound of 0.2 in 29%, 11%, and 8% of splits, respectively. The procedure provides additional evidence for provisional model comparison while allowing judgment to be deferred; it complements external validation, with caution required when censoring compromises confidence-envelope coverage.
翻译:暂无翻译