Empirical research on perception and cognition has laid the foundation for visualization design, often yielding useful design guidelines for practitioners. However, it remains uncertain how well practitioners stay informed about such crucial visualization design knowledge. In this paper, we employed a mixed-method approach to explore the knowledge gap between visualization research and real-world design guidelines. We initially collected existing design guidelines from various sources and empirical studies from diverse publishing venues, analyzing their alignment and uncovering missing links and inconsistent knowledge. Subsequently, we conducted surveys and interviews with practitioners and researchers to gain further insights into their experiences and attitudes towards design guidelines and empirical studies, and their views on the knowledge gap between research and practice. Our findings highlight the similarities and differences in their perspectives and propose strategies to bridge the divide in visualization design knowledge.
翻译:关于感知与认知的实证研究为可视化设计奠定了基础,通常能为实践者提供有用的设计指南。然而,实践者能否充分掌握这些关键的可视化设计知识仍不确定。本文采用混合方法探索可视化研究与实际设计指南之间的知识差距。我们首先从多种来源收集现有设计指南,并从不同出版渠道收集实证研究,分析两者的一致性,揭示缺失环节与矛盾知识。随后,我们对实践者和研究者开展问卷调查与访谈,深入了解他们对设计指南和实证研究的经验与态度,以及他们对研究与实践中知识差距的看法。研究结果凸显了双方观点的异同,并提出了弥合可视化设计知识鸿沟的策略。