In lieu of abstract, first paragraph reads: Six months after the author derived a constant of motion for a 1D damped harmonic oscillator [1], a similar result appeared by Liu, Madhavan, and Tegmark [2, 3], without citing the author. However, their derivation contained six serious errors, causing both their method and result to be incorrect. In this Comment, those errors are reviewed.
翻译:代替摘要,首段内容如下:在作者推导出一维阻尼谐振子的运动常数六年后[1],Liu、Madhavan和Tegmark发表了类似结果[2, 3],但未引用作者的工作。然而,他们的推导包含六处严重错误,导致其方法与结论均不正确。本评论将逐一审视这些错误。