Deep neural networks are increasingly utilized in various machine learning tasks. However, as these models grow in complexity, they often face calibration issues, despite enhanced prediction accuracy. Many studies have endeavored to improve calibration performance through the use of specific loss functions, data preprocessing and training frameworks. Yet, investigations into calibration properties have been somewhat overlooked. Our study leverages the Neural Architecture Search (NAS) search space, offering an exhaustive model architecture space for thorough calibration properties exploration. We specifically create a model calibration dataset. This dataset evaluates 90 bin-based and 12 additional calibration measurements across 117,702 unique neural networks within the widely employed NATS-Bench search space. Our analysis aims to answer several longstanding questions in the field, using our proposed dataset: (i) Can model calibration be generalized across different datasets? (ii) Can robustness be used as a calibration measurement? (iii) How reliable are calibration metrics? (iv) Does a post-hoc calibration method affect all models uniformly? (v) How does calibration interact with accuracy? (vi) What is the impact of bin size on calibration measurement? (vii) Which architectural designs are beneficial for calibration? Additionally, our study bridges an existing gap by exploring calibration within NAS. By providing this dataset, we enable further research into NAS calibration. As far as we are aware, our research represents the first large-scale investigation into calibration properties and the premier study of calibration issues within NAS. The project page can be found at https://www.taolinwei.com/calibration-study

翻译：深度神经网络越来越多地被应用于各种机器学习任务中。然而，随着这些模型复杂度的提升，尽管预测精度有所提高，它们常常面临校准问题。许多研究致力于通过使用特定的损失函数、数据预处理和训练框架来改善校准性能。然而，对校准特性的探讨在一定程度上被忽视了。我们的研究利用神经架构搜索（NAS）搜索空间，提供了一个详尽的模型架构空间以深入探索校准特性。我们专门构建了一个模型校准数据集。该数据集在广泛使用的NATS-Bench搜索空间中，针对117,702个独特的神经网络，评估了90种基于分箱的校准测量指标和12种额外的校准测量指标。我们的分析旨在利用所提出的数据集回答该领域中几个长期存在的问题：（i）模型校准能否在不同数据集之间泛化？（ii）鲁棒性能否用作校准测量指标？（iii）校准指标有多可靠？（iv）后处理校准方法是否对所有模型产生一致影响？（v）校准与精度如何相互影响？（vi）分箱大小对校准测量有何影响？（vii）哪些架构设计有利于校准？此外，我们的研究填补了NAS中校准探索的空白。通过提供该数据集，我们促进了NAS校准的进一步研究。据我们所知，我们的工作是首次针对校准特性的大规模研究，也是NAS中校准问题的开创性研究。项目页面可访问https://www.taolinwei.com/calibration-study。