Emerging technologies introduce sociotechnical tensions that call for closer collaboration between technology design and policy. In this work, we introduce Design-Policy Adversarial Futuring, a scenario-based workshop method that supports design-policy engagement by structuring contestation between design and policy perspectives. We report on a workshop conducted in the autonomous mobility domain with 12 HCI researchers, used to explore and demonstrate the method in practice. The workshop illustrates how the adversarial futuring method can surface shifting harms, translate policy abstractions into situated use, and legitimise extreme ideas while maintaining grounded policy reasoning. This work contributes a reusable, exploratory method for supporting HCI-policy collaboration through contestation, which can be adapted across emerging technological domains.
翻译:新兴技术引发了社会技术张力,迫切需要技术设计与政策之间更紧密的协作。本文提出"设计-政策对抗性未来构建"(Design-Policy Adversarial Futuring)这一基于场景的工作坊方法,通过结构化设计视角与政策视角之间的争论来支持设计-政策协同。我们报告了在自主移动出行领域与12名人机交互(HCI)研究人员共同开展的工作坊实践,以探索和展示该方法的应用。工作坊案例表明,对抗性未来构建方法能够揭示动态变化的危害、将政策抽象转化为具体情境、在保持务实政策推理的同时使极端想法合理化。本研究贡献了一种可复用的探索性方法,通过争论促进HCI-政策协作,并可适配应用于各类新兴技术领域。